Economic and monetary policy outlook
SPEECH DIGEST
HAWKISH high confidence · 19.0k characters readLogan used the Dallas Fed energy conference to put hard numbers on her hawkishness: the funds rate sits at least 50bp below modestly restrictive, she wants at least two more 25bp hikes, and she holds out the option of moving faster this winter than the FOMC has so far this fall. She also flagged this morning's hotter-than-expected October CPI as a reason PCE could surprise higher in a couple of weeks. Crucially this is a speech about the destination, not a protest vote: she defends the October skip and would pause after two more moves, so it caps as well as extends the hiking path.
What’s new: Logan is a known hawk and the direction of this speech was priced. The new content is calibration: a stated 50bp gap to modestly restrictive, an explicit floor of two more 25bp hikes, permission to accelerate this winter, and a live data warning that this morning's October CPI prints raise the risk on October PCE. The other genuinely new item is methodological: her staff argues the Dallas trimmed mean (2.3%) is biased low right now by the mix of price increases and decreases, which undercuts the single most-cited dovish inflation series on the Street.
KEY FINDINGS
- Logan states the FOMC needs at least two more 25bp increases and that it may be possible to move more rapidly this winter than it has moved so far this fall. This is a faster and further path than a 25bp-per-meeting cadence, so front-end pricing and the near-term hiking premium have to carry more term premium.
- She estimates the funds target range is at least 50bp below the level that would create some modest restriction, with eight published models putting the neutral real rate at 1 to 1.85 percent and the real funds rate at 78bp. Her framework says policy is still a quarter point easier than the lowest neutral estimate, which is the argument for selling the front end rather than fading the move.
- October CPI, released this morning, came in above expectations and she is concerned PCE inflation could rise when October data arrive in a couple of weeks. A sitting hawk pre-committing to a hot PCE print removes the excuse to soften in December and keeps short-rate risk skewed to the upside.
- Non-housing, non-transportation core services rose 3.2% year over year, which she says is eight tenths above the pace historically consistent with target, and argues the Dallas trimmed mean understates the trend because the mix of price changes is dropping too many increases. This guts the case that the inflation trend is closer to 2 percent than core PCE suggests, so the low trimmed-mean prints lose their power to rally the front end.
- She calls the labor market balanced and even tightening a bit, with unemployment just above 4 percent and job gains above trend labor force growth, and says the economy is achieving maximum employment. With one mandate met, the dual-mandate trade-off no longer restrains tightening, which removes the dovish argument for holding rates here.
- After two more increases she would pause and examine developments, and she frames the October skip as a timing decision that does not change the destination. This caps the terminal rate and argues against extrapolating the hawkishness into a long hiking cycle, so the curve should bear-steepen rather than flatten outright.
FROM THE DOCUMENT
It remains clear to me, given the current outlook, that the FOMC needs to implement at least two more 25-basis-point rate increases.
I currently estimate that the fed funds target range is at least 50 basis points—half a percentage point—below the level that would create some modest restriction and begin to bring the inflation trend back to target.
The Consumer Price Index for October came out this morning. It was higher than expected. I am concerned that PCE inflation could rise when we receive those data for October in a couple of weeks.
It may be possible to move more rapidly this winter than the FOMC has moved so far this fall.
Thank you, Cortney [Cowley], for that kind introduction. I’m delighted to welcome everyone to the Dallas Fed’s Houston branch. It’s great to be here with my colleague Jeff Schmid, president of the Kansas City Fed, and with all of you. This is the 11th joint energy conference of the Dallas and Kansas City Feds, and it just keeps getting better. In large part, that’s thanks to all of you who join us for this event and share your expertise as speakers and audience members. Thank you for being here. Thank you, also, to everyone at the Dallas and Kansas City banks and on site here in Houston who put in the effort to make this day possible. I’m looking forward to an amazing day of dialogue and learning. You can’t understand the U.S. economy without understanding energy. Energy is a critical input to practically every industry, from traditional manufacturing to data centers. The cost of energy shows up in everything we buy. The ways we produce and consume energy shape how geopolitics affects America’s future. The Dallas and Kansas City Federal Reserve Districts contribute nearly half of U.S. energy GDP, and our two banks are committed to thoroughly understanding this sector. At the Dallas